Probiotics—Worthwhile or Just a Waste?
Yesterday afternoon, as Margot and I sat studying, I was surprised to come across a picture of a familiar bottle:
There’s kombucha in my homework! The picture even depicts my (elusive) favorite flavor, Divine Grape.
Once I actually read the accompanying text, I understood why kombucha might appear in a microbiology textbook—it’s just one of many products currently being marketed as a “probiotic.”
According to the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization and the World Health Organization, probiotics may be defined as follows:
“Probiotics are suspensions of live microorganisms that, when administered in adequate amounts, confer a perceived health benefit on the host.”
The theory is that consumption of foods (and yummy fermented beverages) aid in changing or re-establishing gastrointestinal microbial flora to promote health.
Mmm. Microbes. Tasty.
Don’t stock up on Activia just yet, my friends. According to the available scientific research, probiotics may provide short-term benefits…but evidence indicating their long-term benefits is lacking. To date, there has yet to be a study conducted in which probiotics have conferred lasting, positive health effects.
Nonetheless, research has demonstrated that intestinal microflora can be changed rapidly upon consumption of probiotics.
Bottom Line: I say, keep consuming probiotic products if you enjoy the flavor and the sense of well-being they may provide. I love my kombucha, so I don’t plan on giving it up anytime soon. However, until further research is conducted, don’t expect these products to reverse gastrointestinal disease in the long-term.
Do you regularly consume probiotic products? Do you think they make a significant difference in your overall health?
Also, just for fun—if you’re a kombucha drinker, what’s your favorite flavor?
Onto the grub!
As I mentioned yesterday, I have tempeh bacon in the house. The Elvis had to appear on the breakfast table eventually.
A few weeks ago, my Yummus Hummus post sparked some conversation about the wonders of pesto hummus. It sparked a craving in my culinary brain…so I made my own batch of it for lunch. I didn’t use my original recipe, however—I cheated and used store-bought pesto, but I added more fresh basil to the mix at least.
Now that Seth is gone for the week, I used this sudden abundance of “me time” to make Ellie’s Crab Cakes with Smarter Tartar.
My tweaks:
-I omitted the egg, as it’s difficult to scale down a recipe to use a fraction of an egg.
-I used claw crab meat instead of lump—I’m on a limited budget!
To be frank, these crab cakes were a little meh. The texture was a little off—they didn’t hold together very well, probably because I didn’t have the egg in there as a binder. Furthermore, the flavor was just salty more than anything else. I much preferred Ellie’s Salmon Cakes with Ginger Sesame Sauce. At least the tartar sauce was good—I licked that little bowl clean!
OK, I am off to watch TLC and pretend to study. Good night!
Filed under: Meals
















Caroline Yoder, dietitian-to-be and all-around foodie.



TLC=so addicting. I love getting my probiotics in my yogurt. I try to have it everyday.
Gingerade all the way
BroccoliHut Reply:
July 27th, 2011 at 4:19 pm
Dad tells me you tried a new brand of kombucha recently–Carpe Diem? Was it as good as GT’s?
I like probiotics, they definitely help me out! I love both yogurt and kombucha, and my favorite flavor is the synergy trilogy – it is just too good!!
Ana
I don’t consume many probiotics, though they’ve been recommended to me plenty for my GERD. I don’t do yogurt, and I can’t afford kombucha regularly. When I do drink the stuff, though, I love the passionfruit flavor. Yum!
BroccoliHut Reply:
July 27th, 2011 at 10:24 am
Kombucha is definitely an indulgence item for me too! I buy it only occasionally…or when my dad takes me out to lunch at Whole Foods
Interesting! I always advise patients to get yogurt with active cultures when I put them on short-term oral antibiotic therapy… And it’s really helped to keep the GI healthy in the patients that actually take the advice!! I do the same for myself as well when I’ve had to take antibiotics. But yea, otherwise I don’t bother with probiotics everyday.
I just tried the strawberry today- I like the taste, I like the way it makes me feel but I don’t believe that it is magical probiotic juice ya know! I think there are much less expensive options out there to get even more probiotics!
I like the trilogy, passionberry, & no. 9. Luckily we sell them at my job & I can buy them at wholesale price or I would be quite broke:)
I don’t take probiotics for the sake of taking probiotics, but I do try and incorporate fermented foods into my diet, like yogurt, kefir, miso, sauerkraut, kimchi, etc, because they are healthful for the digestive system. Even if their effects are short term, I don’t see that as a bad thing. But that is also why one would need to consume them on a regular basis
And I just spied a package of tempeh bacon in my freezer. Me thinks I need to take it out so I can make sammiches!